Assessing the Assessors
- This topic has 1 reply, 2 voices, and was last updated 9 years ago by .
- The forum ‘Band’ is closed to new topics and replies.
Standard #7 Evaluating music and music performances.
We’re moving towards a model where 90%+ of our Assessments are Summative Assessments, with a de-emphasis on the Formative Assessment. The discussion therein is for another day. My question for anyone out there is this:
We’re teaching our students how to evaluate a performance of music. We’re using an Assessment form from our state’s Music association that I modified for 7th grade band student use. I’ve gone through the different categories (Tone/Balance, Intonation, Technique, Expression) I will have them evaluate and taught them what to listen for and how to express that on the form. I even put space under each category for the students to justify their assessment and make suggestions for improvement.
The question is this; how do I assess their assessment? We have a form we created to assess all of the skills they demonstrate on their instrument (scales, reading/performing rhythms, etc.) with Mastery Levels indicated (Advanced, Proficient, Basic, Minimal, and Not Observed). Any thoughts about what I can include on an assessment form for their own assessment of someone else’s performance? What criteria do the students need to meet to be considered “Proficient” at Evaluating a music performance?
I know it has been almost a year since your post, so I don’t even know if you still want a reply. If so, I would say that you should make them justify every rating/ranking they assign. That way you have clear evidence of their comprehension of the subject.
A Form & Analysis professor of mine in college “gave” me “F”s on, I think, 6 papers in a row. Perfect and always correct as I know I am, I approached her to inquire about this undoubted mistake. She said, “I understand what you are going for and I could possibly agree. However, you must justify your arguement. I shouldn’t have to guess. If you can justify your opinion, I know you understand the concepts I went over.”
Strictly Necessary Cookie should be enabled at all times so that we can save your preferences for cookie settings.
If you disable this cookie, we will not be able to save your preferences. This means that every time you visit this website you will need to enable or disable cookies again.