Who Actually Quits Musical Instrument Instruction — Children or Their Parents?

Who Actually Quits Musical Instrument Instruction — Children or Their Parents?

By Anthony Mazzocchi

Article originally posted on The Music Parents’ Guide

How many times have we heard from adults that they wish their parents didn’t allow them to quit their musical instrument when they were younger?

There comes a time in a large percentage of music students’ lives when they want to quit their instrument — and more often than not, parents allow them to do it. But is the child quitting . . . or is the parent?

 

Topp_Yimgrimm/iStock/Thinkstock
Topp_Yimgrimm/iStock/Thinkstock

 

I remember wanting to quit the trombone when I was in middle school. Honestly, it’s hard to remember why. It could have been peer pressure, boredom, or something else — but I had my mind made up. I shudder to think of what my life would be like now if my mother had decided to quit as well and give in to my pleas.

Ultimately, it is important to understand that when it comes to music education and other transformative activities that require some grit in order to succeed, most children go through a period of time where they must succeed despite themselves. They must be encouraged and supported through the tough times, not given a pass. It is only at a certain point that children — and parents — can make an informed decision to quit their musical instrument, and that point is usually much later, not sooner, than one may think.

Here are a few ways that parents are the ones that quit music instruction, and some thoughts on overcoming the tough times with our children that are bound to occur:

“I can’t bug my child to do one more thing.” I have heard this line so many times as a teacher and administrator. A parent tells the teacher that their child will be discontinuing music because they haven’t had any luck getting their child to practice, and the “child doesn’t want to play anymore.” In addition, the parent says the child “seems to be over-scheduled and is overwhelmed with the demanding school curriculum.”

This parent has clearly given up.

There are many things that children need to do that they do not want to do. They don’t want to bathe, do homework, brush their teeth, or do their chores oftentimes. But we as adults understand that we would be teaching them to be irresponsible if we gave in. We also understand that children are not old or mature enough to make many life decisions — but when it comes to quitting music instruction the rules somehow seem to change. The truth is that we can insist our child do “one more thing,” and if that’s really not humanly possible, a curricular activity such as music should not be at the bottom of that list.

Parents have overcommitted their child. Our children are growing up in a time where the U.S. has turned into a society of “overachievers”. Downtime or activities that are perceived to be “fun” (i.e. music and the arts) are considered wasted time because concrete results are not being measured and money (and a job) is not at the end of the equation. Children have so many choices of ways to “enrich” their lives that quitting has become an easy response to frustration or boredom. Most adults regret many of the things in life that they quit, especially because they could have had stuck it out, reached a good level of proficiency and found that enjoyment that seemed to elude them earlier. Parents need to remember this fact and encourage their children to stick with music instruction for at least two years, if not through middle school.

Parents must remember what their goals for their child’s education are. Perseverance, commitment, loyalty, and grit are all values I hope that I — and my schools — instill in my children. Learning to endure something even when it temporarily becomes boring or unpleasant or when the teacher isn’t the most engaging person in the world is a lesson truly worth teaching. I would argue that the time you let your child walk away from something just because at that moment it doesn’t suit them is the last time you may have any credibility with them about endurance or resilience ever again.

Parents, teachers and students have a misguided view of passion. Parents often talk about helping kids find their passions. When parents allow their children to quit music, we often hear excuses such as, “Music is not where my child’s passion lies, it seems.” But most of the time, passions do not always appear out of nowhere; they are often a result of hard work and dedication — the happiness that comes from doing something well over a period of time. I have spent most of my life reaping the rewards of a life devoted to music, yet in 7th grade I was begging to quit. And there are thousands upon thousands of other children who were not allowed to quit who have gone on to rewarding lives in many fields that would never have been possible if not for their musical education.

Your child’s experience with their music studies will shape their adult lives more than you will ever know.

Parents need to embrace the struggle that their children are facing. The reward of performing a piece of music after overcoming obstacles during practice is a great vehicle for parents to teach their children that true growth occurs when we struggle a bit. Learning to deal with struggle yields some of the greatest benefits imaginable over time when applied to other areas of life. But a child’s struggle is a parents struggle as well, of course. There are bad days — and some really frustrating days. There may be tantrums and miserable practices and screaming scenes where you may feel as if you are at the end of your rope. But if you stick with it, your children will have long, enduring relationships with instructors and classmates who will change and enrich their lives. Don’t forget to reach out to your child’s teacher for extra help during these challenging times — I promise you that they will pass.

Your child’s experience with their music studies will shape their adult lives more than you will ever know. They will be different people in the best way imaginable — people who would be far poorer intellectually without music in their life. Let’s not kid ourselves — children quit things all the time. Sometimes it’s even the right thing to do, but sometimes they are simply bored or don’t like the teacher or would just rather do nothing at home — and that is not acceptable or in their best interest over the long-term. Deciding when to let your child quit is a difficult problem that never goes away, but it is safe to say that one year is simply not enough time for anyone to decide whether to stay with musical instrument instruction or not.

Maybe you didn’t study music. Maybe you quit prematurely and you didn’t even realize it — but the road is open to your children, so steer them down it. They will never tell you later in life that they are angry at you for not letting them quit.

About the author:

band director

A GRAMMY® nominated music educator, Anthony Mazzocchi has performed as a trombonist with the Los Angeles Philharmonic, New Jersey Symphony, San Diego Symphony, San Diego Opera, Riverside Symphony, Key West Symphony, in various Broadway shows and numerous recordings and movie soundtracks.

Tony has served as faculty or as a frequent guest lecturer at The Juilliard School, Manhattan School of Music, New York University, and Mannes College of Music. He has taught students from K-college, and has served as a district Director of Fine and Performing Arts in the South Orange/Maplewood School District. Tony has been a consultant for arts organizations throughout the NY/NJ area.

Tony blogs about how to be a successful music parent at The Music Parent’s Guide, and the book by the same name can be bought here. He has written a method book for music teachers called The Band Director’s Method Book Companion.

Tony is currently Associate Director of the John J. Cali School of Music at Montclair State University in New Jersey. He is also Executive Director of the Kinhaven Summer Music School in Weston, Vermont. Tony is a clinician for Courtois – Paris.

Tony will be presenting on his topic “Parents on Board! How to Engage Parents in Their Child’s Music Education” at the 2015 NAfME National In-Service Conference this month in Nashville, TN! Register today!

professional development

 

Join us for more than 300 innovative professional development sessions, nightly entertainment, extraordinary performances from across the country, a wild time at the Give a Note Extravaganza, and tons of networking opportunities with over 3,000+ other music educators! Learn more and register today: http://bit.ly/Nafville2015. And follow the hashtag #Nafville2015!

 


Catherina Hurlburt, Communications Manager, October 23, 2015. © National Association for Music Education (NAfME.org)

  • Mr. DeMasi

    Like the author, I wanted to quit in middle school. I was in 6th grade and no longer wanted to play the trumpet because I didn’t like my band teacher that year. When I told my dad, he talked me out of quitting because he regretted quitting band in high school in order to march with his sport’s team in the town parade. I took his advice, continued to play the trumpet, and now love my job teaching 4th and 5th grade band students. Now I tell my students that are leaving my elementary program, “do not quit because you don’t get along with your teacher; most likely, you’ll have a different one the following year.” I hope that many of them will remember my story and not quit for that or any other reason that can be rectified.

  • Helen Southerland

    Thank you for your article. I quit learning piano at the end of grade 7 because I wanted to grow my finger nails long like all the other girls! I had been learning for 4 years. Fortunately that wasn’t the end of my music education as I was also learning clarinet and continued through to the end of high school exams (year 12 in Australia). I am now a primary school music teacher, teaching generalised music skills to whole classes from grade 1 to 6 and I love my job. I only wish that I had continued to develop my piano skills, as I would be better at my job.
    My son is now 11 and learns guitar and trumpet. He begged to be allowed to quit guitar after 6 months. He has now been learning for 2 years and has actually thanked me for not letting him quit. He loves it now, though we still have the practise battle at times. We are now having the same quitting discussions after 9 months of trumpet, but will persevere.

  • Brady Massey

    How would I get permission to have our local newspaper publish excerpts from this article?

    • kristenrNAfME

      Hi Brady, please email our Communications Manager, Catherina Hurlburt: CatherinaH@nafme.org

  • Robert Adams

    I never wanted to quit, I just didn’t want to practice. I wasn’t doing as well as my friends, so I was discouraged and wanted to give up. When I finally got my way, I was one miserable kid. School grades went down and I was unhappy. Luckily my teacher put all this together and got me back in the band, and I went on to become a music teacher myself. There’s always a balance between experiencing success (we all need encouragement from success) and natural passion. When the two work together, kids are unstoppable. http://mramusicplace.net

  • Kat Holmes

    I’m in college now, and I’m so glad my parents never let me give up music. They let me change instruments, but I was never able to give it up. Tbh, music is the only class from high school that I miss. I didn’t take a music class last quarter, but I am this quarter. It’s my favorite class (other than having to trek my tuba 3/4 of a mile to my dorm if I want to practice)

  • Jon Kitchen

    I believe that it depends on the child’s desires. As a child I wanted to be taught. I literally begged for piano instruction.Because my mother had misgivings about certain teachers, she made me wait until she found a teacher she trusted.The same teacher taught a friend of mine, but told my mother that the child wanted to quit, and the mother would not let him.This is my point: a child that wants to stop should not be forced by parents to continue.However, if a child wants to learn, then help them ,please.

  • Lydia Reznichenko

    I am in the same situation with my kid. Even though I didn’t let him to quit, just changing teacher and instrument, I do know adults who played all the way through high school, finished, relieved and never touched the instrument again in their life. They think it was waste of time, nerves and brought them to hate music.