Announcing a Conversation Series on Actualizing Equity in Music Education
June 2021: In the coming weeks and months, NAfME President Mackie V. Spradley will lead discussions among music educators about actualizing equity in music education. Dates, times, and details will be announced soon.
The next events in the series are:
● Celebrate Juneteenth! Celebrate the new law establishing Juneteenth National Independence Day, and view the latest entry in the NAfME Conversation Series on Actualizing Equity: The Significance of Juneteenth. Sign up to receive updates about this conversation.
● Actualizing Equity in Music Education (Pre-Symposium) – The NAfME Equity Committee and equity groups within each state Music Education Association continue to make intentional efforts to identify systems, policies, and practices that create barriers to equity in music education. On June 12, we held part one of a series that will focus on establishing a shared understanding of equity, learning how to facilitate difficult conversations centered on race, examining discourse through the lens of equity, implementing assessment protocols to identify blindspots, and creating a repository of resources that can support the ongoing work.
● Eradicating Systemic Racism in Music Education – StopAsianHate – On June 7, 2021 Asian American and Pacific Islander music leaders continued the conversation on systemic racism in music education. The discussion centered on the power of discourse to impact our lived experiences, thoughts, actions, and ways we show up in the world.
● Over the 2020-2021 school year, NAfME members participated in a series of virtual Town Hall meetings about the next NAfME Strategic Plan, with a focus on the question: “What can we do to eradicate systemic racism and center equity?” President Spradley recommended that interested members review the following historical items to fully engage in the dialogue:
- Framing the Question: Statement from NAfME President Mackie V. Spradley
- NAfME Diversity, Equity, Inclusion, and Access Study executive summary
- Current Strategic Plan
- Vision 2020
- NAfME Position Statements
- NAfME History, Constitution, Structure
NAfME Resources for Diversity, Equity, Inclusion, and Access in Music Education
- What We Believe: Black Lives Matter
- NAfME Diversity, Equity, Inclusion, and Access Study
- NAfME Position Statements
- Ideas from NAfME Members: Music in a Minuet Blog offers professional development through DEIA-focused blog posts by NAfME members.
- NAfME Public Policy
The Civil Rights Act and the Elementary and Secondary Education Act have worked in tandem in, first, supporting desegregation, and, today, to ensure that students who are traditionally underserved receive a quality education. The latest iteration of ESEA, the Every Students Succeeds Act, passed in 2015, calls for a well-rounded education, which includes music, for all students. Title IV-A of ESSA, acknowledges that students can be discriminated against when trying to gain access to enriching subjects, including music. Advocating for music education for all students is a civil rights issue. NAfME, along with its members of the Music Education Policy Roundtable, have endorsed policies that will help achieve the goal of all students having access to a music education.
- NAfME Roundtable Legislative Requests
- Fiscal Year 2021 Appropriations
- Emergency Funding to Address the Homework Gap
- Emergency Funding to Back-fill State Education Budgets
- Funding for the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA)
- Guarantee Access to Arts and Music Education Act
- Higher Education Act Reauthorization
- Rebuild America Schools Act
Reach out to your member of Congress Grassroots Action Center on issues of equity and access for music education.
Peer-Reviewed Articles from NAfME Journals
- Forthcoming September 2020 issue includes a special focus on Policy in Music Education and how it can lead to greater inclusion/access for all. Available online by September 10.
- June 2020 “Music Education, Curriculum Design, and Assessment: Imagining a More Equitable Approach,” Jennifer Mellizo states that conventional curricula may place some students at a disadvantage in school music classrooms and offers five steps toward equality.
- June 2020 “Sharing Global Musics: El Sistema Sweden Summer Camp” by Tricia Tunstall describes a Swedish summer music camp in which all students are welcome and spontaneity fosters inclusion.
- June 2020, “Factors that Affect Participation in Secondary School Music: Reducing Barriers and Increasing Access by Mara E. Culp and Matthew Clauhs looks at practices that promote increased access to and participation in high-school music.
- June 2020 “Equity in Music Education: Making a Space for Everyone” by Mallory Alekna and Soyeon Kang describes an experiment in creative placemaking and music-making at Arizona State University.
- March 2020 “Equity in Music Education: Cultural Appropriation vs. Cultural Appreciation and Understanding the Difference” by Karen Howard
- March 2019,“Teaching about the Korean Ganggangsullae Folk Tradition in General Music Class,” Gina J. Yi examines practices in Korea and offers students and teachers get a glimpse of Korean culture.
- March 2019, “Equity in Music Education: The Music We Speak: Language and Power in the Urban Music Classroom” by Judy Lewis.
- September 2019 issue is a special focus on Popular Music in Music Education and includes articles on diversifying what we teach and who we reach via popular music in the classroom.
- December 2018, “Music Education to Train Hearing Abilities in Children with Cochlear Implants” by James L. Reifinger Jr.
- December 2018, “Sharing Global Musics: An Introduction to the Music of China” by John L. Whitener and Feigun Shu
- December 2018, “Equity in Music Education: Back to Class: Music Education and Poverty” by Vincent C. Bates.
- June 2020, “‘Anything is Better than Nothing!’ Inservice Teacher Preparation for Teaching Students with Disabilities” by Rachel Grimsby.
- June 2019, “A Cultural Immersion Field Experience: Examining Preservice Music Teachers’ Beliefs About Cultural Differences in the Music Classroom” by Andrea J. VanDeusen.
- June 2019, “Considering Antiracism in Student Teacher Placement” by Matthew C. Fiorentino.
- April 2020, “Predictors of Taking Elective Music Courses in Middle School Among Low-SES, Ethnically Diverse Students in Miami” by Alenamie Alegrado and Adam Winsler.
- October 2019, “Who Enrolls in High School Music? A National Profile of U.S. Students, 2009–2013, Kenneth Elpus and Carlos Abril.
- April 2019, “Selected Nonmusic Predictors of Urban Students’ Decisions to Enroll and Persist in Middle and High School Music Ensemble Electives” by Daryl W. Kinney.
- July 2019, “Features of University Environments That Support Well-Being as Perceived by Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, and Questioning Undergraduate Music and Art Students, Nicholas E. Roseth.
Teaching Music (not peer-reviewed, but available to all NAfME members with login.)
“Secondary Vocal Education in a Pandemic: Diversify Practice to Find New Meaning” by Meagan Dissenger, who asks in the August 2020 issue how we can make high-school choral curricula appeal to a wider range of students in our communities. p. 14.
“The Blues: A Vehicle for Listening and Creativity” by Matt Pivec, who states in the August 2020 issue that he believes that students at many levels can use to become better listeners and musical creators. p. 18.
- “Teaching Music in a New Normal” in the August 2020 issue looks at what a number of teachers are doing to help keep all students engaged and safe. p. 24.
Library of Congress Teaching with Primary Sources Curriculum Units includes general music units focused on social justice; choral units focused on folk/popular music, spiritual; band and orchestra units focused on student engagement and issues of diversity. Available free to all.
HBCU Schools Offering Music Programs – Search programs by state or geographic region. Once you click on a given institution, you can see all of the undergraduate programs offered, including if the music programs include music teacher education.
NAfME Academy includes an entire section on “Inclusion in the Music Classroom.” Other webinars include Gospel Music; Diversity in the Choral Classroom: Adversity or Electricity; Does Diversity Matter; Hip-Hop, Ya Don’t Stop; Music Careers in the Military. Available to members for $20; nonmembers $100 annually.
- “Composing in Bite-Sized Chunks” by Rob Deemer
- “Teaching Students with Disabilities during COVID-19” by Alice Hammel
- “Smithsonian Folkways Recordings: In Partnership with World Music Pedagogy” by Patricia Sheehan Campbell
- “Adapting Primary Sources to Build Responsive Students” by Carolyn Bennett, Tom Dean, Armalyn De La O, & Johanna Siebert
- “Using Google Earth to Build Global Musicianship in and out of Your Classroom” by Rosalee Goley
- “Thinking about Teaching the Music of Indigenous North American Cultures” by Patricia Shehan Campbell
- “Embracing Music in Multiculturally Sensitive Ways: Northeastern Brazilian Traditions” by Juliana Cantarelli Vita
- “From Conflict to Celebration: Music from the Middle East through the Lens of World Music Pedagogy” by William Coppola
- “Performing Moses Hogan Spirituals” by Loneka Wilkinson Battiste
- “Landó for the Band: A Brief Exploration of Afro-Peruvian Music through World Music Pedagogy” by with Chris Mena
- “Discussing the Diversification of State Repertoire Lists” by with Dr. Rob Deemer; Cecilia Clark; Quincy C. Hilliard; Amy Rever-Oberle; Cory Meals; and Brandon Houghtalen
- “Teaching General Music during COVID-19 through the Lens of Music Learning Theory and World Music Drumming” by Patty Bourne, Paul Corbière, Jill Reese, and Rob Lyda
- “Culturally Responsive Choral Pedagogy: Learning from Students’ Experiences” by Julia T. Shaw
- “TeachRock: Social Justice Resources for Blending Learning” by Christine Nick and Joshua Zarbo
- “Creative Repertoire Initiative” by Alex Shapiro, Brian Balmages, Frank Ticheli, Jennifer Jolley, and Rob Deemer
- “Do You Want to Celebrate Hispanic Heritage Month in Your Music Class?” by Ramon Rivera and Jacob Scherr
“Making Good Choices: How Can Teachers Better Research Repertoire for the Classroom?” by Brandi Waller-Pace, Lorelei Batislaong, and Michelle McCauley of Decolonizing the Music Room
Educators can receive one free professional development contact hour for most webinars. To receive the link to the associated quiz, contact John Donaldson at email@example.com
- Engaging Musical Practices: A Sourcebook for Elementary General Music. Includes world music and other nontraditional music-making approaches for young learners (Rowman & Littlefield/NAfME publication, 2018).